Barnsley vs Rotherham Prediction & Betting Tips (26 August)

Barnsley welcome Rotherham to Oakwell for a tantalizing EFL Cup second-round clash on August 26, with both South Yorkshire sides entering the tie on contrasting trajectories. Barnsley, under the stewardship of Conor Hourihane, have stitched together an impressive unbeaten run, including a gritty 1-0 away win over Peterborough and a comeback victory against Burton. Hourihane’s tactical tweaks—particularly the integration of Davis Keillor-Dunn and the experienced David McGoldrick—have injected attacking flair and resilience. With Vimal Yoganathan returning from suspension and Patrick Kelly impressing in midfield, the Tykes look well-balanced and primed for a cup surge.

Rotherham, meanwhile, are still searching for rhythm under new manager Matt Hamshaw. Their early season has been marred by inconsistency and a growing injury list. Key striker Sam Nombe, who netted twice on opening day, remains sidelined, while midfielders Josh Benson and Kian Spence are also unavailable. The Millers scraped past Salford City on penalties in the first round but were soundly beaten 3-0 by Cardiff in their most recent outing. With Jordan Hugill leading the line and Ar’Jany Martha offering support, Rotherham’s attacking options appear limited, especially with Josh Kayode only just returning to training after knee surgery.



Historically, Barnsley have had the upper hand in this fixture, winning both encounters last season without conceding. Their recent form suggests they’ll look to dominate possession and exploit Rotherham’s defensive frailties, particularly in the second half where Barnsley have consistently found goals. Hourihane may rotate slightly, with Reyes Cleary and Caylan Vickers likely to feature, but the core of McGoldrick, Phillips, and Keillor-Dunn should remain intact. Rotherham’s best hope lies in frustrating the hosts early and capitalizing on set pieces, though their lack of firepower and depth could prove costly.

Given the current dynamics, a 2-1 scoreline in favor of Barnsley feels not only plausible but probable. Expect the Tykes to control proceedings, with McGoldrick and Phillips likely to find the net, while Rotherham may snatch a consolation through Hugill or a late substitute. The derby atmosphere will add spice, but Barnsley’s cohesion and momentum should see them through to the next round. For Hamshaw, the fixture may serve as a litmus test for how quickly he can galvanize a depleted squad against a well-oiled rival.

• Summary: Barnsley is going head to head with Rotherham United starting on 26 Aug 2025 at 18:45 UTC at Oakwell Ground stadium, Barnsley city, England. The match is a part of the EFL Cup .
• Barnsley Feedinco Rating: 7.03
• Rotherham Feedinco Rating: 7.22