New York City vs Columbus Crew Prediction & Betting Tips (18 September)

New York City FC and Columbus Crew are set to clash in a pivotal Eastern Conference showdown on September 18, with playoff implications hanging in the balance. NYCFC, currently seventh in the standings, have shown resilience at home, winning eight of their last twelve league matches at Citi Field. Despite a possession rate hovering around 34 percent in recent home games, their efficiency in front of goal has kept them competitive. However, they’ll be without key figures: goalkeeper Matt Freese and defender Thiago Martins are away on international duty, while Jacob Arroyave and Mitja Ilenič remain sidelined with injuries. Tomás Romero is expected to start between the posts, anchoring a backline that will need to be sharp against a Crew side known for their attacking flair.

Columbus Crew arrive in New York sitting fourth in the table, boasting a record of 12 wins, 8 draws, and 5 losses. Their away form, however, tells a different story—winless in seven of their last eight road games, with defensive lapses contributing to an average of 2.33 goals conceded per away match. Rudy Camacho is out with a hamstring injury, and national team call-ups have thinned their ranks, including absences for Nicholas Hagen and Maximilian Arfsten. Coach Wilfried Nancy will likely lean on a 3-4-2-1 setup, with Patrick Schulte in goal and Jacen Russell-Rowe leading the line. The Crew’s recent performances have been marked by high-scoring affairs, but their inability to close out matches away from home remains a concern.



Both teams have had mixed fortunes in their recent outings. NYCFC suffered a narrow 2-1 defeat to D.C. United but bounced back with a gritty win over FC Cincinnati. Alonso Martínez continues to be a standout performer, though his absence due to international duty will be felt. Columbus, meanwhile, edged out Atlanta United in a thrilling 5-4 encounter and held Toronto FC to a 1-1 draw, showcasing their ability to grind out results even when not at full strength. The tactical battle between Pascal Jansen and Wilfried Nancy promises to be intriguing, especially with both managers navigating depleted squads and shifting momentum.

Given the numbers and current form, a 2-1 victory for New York City FC feels like a calculated prediction rather than a hopeful guess. Their home strength, coupled with Columbus’s travel woes and defensive vulnerabilities, tips the balance in favor of the Boys in Blue. Expect a tightly contested match with goals from both sides, but NYCFC’s ability to capitalize on limited chances and maintain composure in front of their home crowd could be the decisive factor.

• Summary: New York City FC is going head to head with Columbus Crew starting on 17 Sept 2025 at 23:30 UTC at Yankee Stadium stadium, Bronx city, USA. The match is a part of the MLS .