New York City vs Seattle Sounders Prediction & Betting Tips (19 October)

New York City FC enters this fixture with a mixed bag of recent performances, having lost narrowly to Philadelphia Union in their last outing. Despite the setback, they remain in playoff contention, sitting 9th in the standings with 56 points. Head coach P. Jansen has been rotating his squad smartly, with midfielder Santiago Rodríguez continuing to be a creative spark in the final third. The return of Thiago Martins from injury has bolstered their backline, while young striker Talles Magno is regaining form at a crucial time. NYCFC’s home form has been a lifeline this season, and they’ll be banking on the energy of the Bronx crowd to push them over the line.

Seattle Sounders, on the other hand, have struggled to find consistency in 2025. Currently 14th in the league with 50 points, they’ve shown flashes of brilliance but have been let down by defensive lapses. Head coach Brian Schmetzer has had to juggle injuries, particularly in defense, with Yeimar Gómez Andrade and Nouhou Tolo both missing key stretches. Offensively, Jordan Morris remains a threat, and Albert Rusnák has been instrumental in midfield transitions. However, their away form has been shaky, and they’ve conceded 47 goals this season—one of the highest in the Western Conference. A trip to New York poses a stern test for a team still searching for rhythm.



Historically, matches between these two sides have been unpredictable, with both teams trading wins over the years. Their last encounter at Yankee Stadium ended in a 1-1 draw, but NYCFC had the better of the chances. The tactical battle between Jansen’s possession-heavy approach and Schmetzer’s counter-attacking blueprint will be fascinating to watch. Set pieces could play a decisive role, especially with NYCFC’s aerial prowess. Both teams are expected to field strong lineups, with no major suspensions reported. The weather forecast suggests cool conditions, which could favor the more physically resilient side in the latter stages of the match.

Taking all factors into account—form, injuries, tactical setups, and home advantage—this match leans slightly in favor of New York City FC. While Seattle will likely find the net through a moment of individual brilliance, NYCFC’s cohesion and attacking depth should see them edge the contest. Expect a tightly contested affair with moments of high drama, but ultimately, the hosts should prevail. Our prediction: a 2-1 victory for New York City FC, keeping their playoff hopes alive and adding another chapter to this growing inter-conference rivalry.

• Summary: New York City FC is going head to head with Seattle Sounders FC starting on 18 Oct 2025 at 22:00 UTC at Yankee Stadium stadium, Bronx city, USA. The match is a part of the MLS .
• Referee: Chris Penso
• New York City Feedinco Rating: 6.95
• Seattle Sounders Feedinco Rating: 7.01