Tottenham vs Everton Prediction & Betting Tips (12 September)

Tottenham Hotspur welcome Everton to the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium on Saturday 12 September 2026 for a Premier League 2026/27 fixture kicking off at 5:30pm. Spurs come into this clash off the back of a hard-fought 0-0 draw away to Nottingham Forest, while their previous home league outing ended in a 0-2 defeat to Newcastle United — results that have put early pressure on the Lilywhites to turn home advantage into points. Everton, meanwhile, remain unbeaten in the league this season after a thrilling 2-2 draw with Manchester United at Hill Dickinson Stadium, a game in which the Toffees twice came from behind to show real resilience under their manager.

The two squads for the 2026/27 season offer plenty of intrigue. Tottenham's roster blends exciting attacking talent such as Omar Marmoush, Mathys Tel, Richarlison, Dominic Solanke, Mohammed Kudus, Mykhailo Mudryk, Sávio and Xavi Simons with a revamped midfield featuring Sandro Tonali, Conor Gallagher and James Maddison, while Pedro Porro, Micky van de Ven, Destiny Udogie and Andy Robertson anchor the defence in front of goalkeepers Antonín Kinský and Martin Dúbravka. Everton will look to Jordan Pickford in goal, a back line led by Jarrad Branthwaite and James Tarkowski, a creative midfield of Jack Grealish, Christian Nørgaard, Carlos Alcaraz and Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall, and a forward line containing Brennan Johnson, Thierno Barry and Tyrique George. The visitors also showed their scoring touch in the EFL Cup with a 0-4 demolition of Preston North End, while Spurs responded to league disappointment by thrashing Charlton 5-1 in the same competition.

On the European odds market for this fixture, Tottenham are clear favourites at around 1.75 to win in the 1X2 market, with the draw priced at approximately 4.00 and an Everton victory available at roughly 4.50 — figures that reflect Spurs' home strength despite their patchy early league form, as well as the Toffees' reputation for grinding out results on the road. The head-to-head history adds spice too, as Spurs edged the most recent meeting 1-0 at home in May 2026, a result that ultimately secured their Premier League survival in dramatic fashion last season.

Our prediction for this match is a 2-1 home victory for Tottenham. Spurs' attacking firepower — led by Marmoush, Kudus and the creative Maddison — should prove too sharp for an Everton side that has drawn its last three league games, but the visitors' unbeaten start and Grealish's playmaking threat mean a tight contest is expected. Expect Tottenham to dominate possession and territory, convert their chances late on, and claim a narrow but deserved three points in front of their own fans on Saturday even